Tanzania Investment and Consultant Group Ltd

| Economic Research Centre

In September 2024, Zanzibar's economy showed notable progress, driven by growth in trade, financial services, and construction, highlighting a shift toward greater sectoral diversity beyond traditional tourism. Revenue collection reached 88.6% of targets, underscoring improvements in fiscal management, yet a budget deficit remains due to rising expenditures. This economic snapshot reflects Zanzibar's steady trajectory toward sustainable development, though continued efforts to balance fiscal needs with growth aspirations will be essential to its long-term economic resilience.

  1. Sectoral Growth:
    • Trade and Financial Services: Zanzibar’s economic expansion has been supported by growth in trade and financial services, both of which are significant drivers of economic activity and diversification. These sectors enhance the island’s capacity for sustainable development beyond traditional industries.
    • Construction: The construction sector has also shown robust growth, indicating infrastructure development and investment in housing and public projects. This growth supports job creation and has positive multiplier effects on the local economy.
  2. Revenue Collection:
    • Target Achievement: Zanzibar achieved 88.6% of its revenue target in August 2024, with total revenue collections amounting to TZS 56.2 billion. This strong performance reflects improved fiscal management and effective tax administration, bolstering government resources to fund essential services and development initiatives.
    • Tax Revenue Contribution: Tax revenue accounted for the majority of collections, reaching TZS 48.7 billion. This reliance on tax revenue highlights improved compliance and enforcement, as well as a broadening tax base that reflects diversified economic activities.
  3. Budget Deficit:
    • Despite solid revenue collection, a budget deficit remains due to spending requirements. While fiscal management has improved, the deficit underscores the need for increased revenues or spending adjustments to achieve fiscal balance without over-relying on debt.
  4. Tourism and Trade:
    • Tourism: As one of Zanzibar’s most significant economic contributors, tourism continues to drive foreign exchange earnings, support jobs, and stimulate related sectors such as hospitality, transportation, and retail.
    • Trade: The growth in trade activities points to Zanzibar’s increased economic integration, particularly through exports and imports that serve both the local population and tourism-related needs. This sector contributes to economic resilience by providing diverse revenue streams.

Zanzibar’s economic performance is marked by progress in trade, financial services, and construction, showing signs of diversification and sustainable development. While revenue collection is strong, achieving 88.6% of targets, the existing budget deficit highlights areas for further fiscal improvements. Together, these indicators point to gradual but steady growth for Zanzibar, aligned with the broader economic goals of Tanzania.

The economic data for Zanzibar in 2024 with a promising trajectory toward growth, diversification, and fiscal improvement, though some challenges remain:

  1. Sectoral Diversification and Resilience:
    • Growth in trade, financial services, and construction suggests that Zanzibar is diversifying its economy beyond traditional sectors like tourism. This diversification enhances resilience, as multiple sectors can drive growth, reducing dependency on a single industry and making the economy more stable during sector-specific downturns.
  2. Improved Fiscal Management:
    • Achieving 88.6% of the revenue target reflects significant progress in fiscal management and revenue collection. Strong tax revenues of TZS 48.7 billion indicate better tax administration and compliance, providing the government with a more stable funding base for essential services and infrastructure projects.
  3. Persistent Budget Deficit:
    • Although revenue collection is strong, the existing budget deficit shows that expenditures are still outpacing revenues. This deficit could limit funds for future development projects or require additional borrowing, which could raise the debt burden. Addressing this gap may involve further revenue enhancements or strategic spending cuts.
  4. Reliance on Tourism and Trade:
    • Tourism remains a major economic driver, bringing in foreign exchange, creating jobs, and supporting various sectors. The growth in trade reflects economic integration and a stable supply chain for local and tourism-related needs. However, tourism dependency can make the economy vulnerable to global events affecting travel, underscoring the need for diversification.
  5. Gradual Economic Progression:
    • Overall, Zanzibar’s growth across sectors, improved revenue collection, and steady infrastructure development indicate gradual economic progression. These advancements align with the broader goals of Mainland Tanzania, positioning Zanzibar as an essential contributor to national economic growth.

Zanzibar’s economic data shows a balanced path of growth, supported by sectoral diversification, fiscal improvements, and reliance on tourism and trade. While progress is steady, the budget deficit highlights a need for careful fiscal management to maintain growth momentum without over-reliance on borrowing. This balanced approach is crucial for building a resilient, diversified economy aligned with Tanzania’s overall development goals.

Addressed Infrastructure, Regulatory Efficiency, and Public Service Challenges

The Business Ready 2024 report provides an assessment of Tanzania's business environment based on three key pillars: Regulatory Framework, Public Services, and Operational Efficiency

  1. Regulatory Framework: Tanzania scored 65.00 points, placing it in the third quintile, meaning its regulatory environment is moderately favorable. This includes regulations that govern business entry, labor, taxation, and financial services, though there is room for improvement in areas like market competition and insolvency.

What it Means: The Regulatory Framework pillar focuses on the laws, rules, and regulations that businesses must follow in Tanzania. A score of 65.00 indicates that while the regulatory environment is moderately favorable, it still has areas that need improvement.

What is Measured: This pillar assesses the rules, laws, and regulations that businesses must follow as they enter, operate, and exit the market. It focuses on whether these regulations are clear, fair, and supportive of entrepreneurial activity.

Key Areas Measured:

What It Tells About Tanzania:

  1. Public Services: Tanzania's score for public services is 51.56 points, placing it in the fourth quintile. This reflects challenges in public service provision that support businesses, including utility services and government institutions related to business regulation.

What it Means: This pillar evaluates the quality of government-provided services that help businesses comply with regulations, such as utility services (electricity, water), online tax services, and other government support structures.

What is Measured: This pillar looks at the quality of public services provided by the government that are necessary for businesses to function, including utility services, government transparency, and the infrastructure that supports business compliance with regulations.

Key Areas Measured:

What It Tells About Tanzania:

  1. Operational Efficiency: Tanzania performed better in operational efficiency with a score of 62.15 points, placing it in the third quintile. This category measures how efficiently businesses can comply with regulations and access public services.

What it Means: The Operational Efficiency pillar measures how easy it is for businesses to comply with regulations and access services. Tanzania’s score in this pillar suggests that businesses face some challenges but generally have moderate success in navigating the regulatory landscape and accessing the services they need.

What is Measured: This pillar evaluates how easy it is for businesses to comply with the regulatory framework and access public services. It measures the practical implementation of the rules and services described under the first two pillars.

Key Areas Measured:

What It Tells About Tanzania:

Tanzania's scores in the Business Ready 2024 report provide valuable insights into the country's economic development by highlighting strengths and challenges in its business environment. Here's a breakdown of what these figures reveal about Tanzania's economic development:

1. Regulatory Framework (Score: 65.00)

2. Public Services (Score: 51.56)

3. Operational Efficiency (Score: 62.15)

Overall Economic Development Insights:

Strategic Recommendations for Economic Development:

  1. Invest in Infrastructure: Improving utility services, especially reliable electricity and internet access, will lower operational costs and improve productivity across sectors, boosting overall economic growth.
  2. Strengthen the Legal and Regulatory Environment: Enhancing regulations related to market competition, insolvency, and business disputes will create a more favorable environment for entrepreneurship and innovation, encouraging more domestic and foreign investment.
  3. Improve Public Service Delivery: Streamlining processes such as tax filing, permit issuance, and customs procedures through digitalization would significantly reduce the cost of doing business and improve Tanzania’s global competitiveness.
Business Ready 2024 Executive SummaryDownload

As of the period ending on December 31, 2023, both NMB Bank and CRDB Bank have exhibited notable financial performance, reflecting various key metrics that are indicative of their operational strength and market presence.

NMB Bank reported total assets amounting to 12.2 trillion Tanzania Shillings, representing a remarkable 19% growth. This increase underscores the bank's ability to expand its asset base, possibly through effective investment strategies or successful acquisition initiatives. On the other hand, CRDB Bank demonstrated a total asset growth of 14%, reaching 13.2 trillion Tanzania Shillings. Although slightly lower than NMB Bank's growth rate, this still signifies a substantial increase in the bank's overall financial standing.

In terms of total deposits, NMB Bank recorded 8.4 trillion Tanzania Shillings, marking an 11% growth. This suggests a consistent influx of funds into the bank, likely driven by customer trust and effective deposit mobilization efforts. CRDB Bank, while also experiencing growth, posted a total deposit figure of 8.9 trillion Tanzania Shillings, reflecting an 8% increase. This showcases the bank's ability to attract and retain deposits, albeit at a slightly lower growth rate compared to NMB Bank.

Loan and advances, a critical aspect of banking operations, showed significant growth for both institutions. NMB Bank reported a loan and advances portfolio of 7.7 trillion Tanzania Shillings, reflecting a substantial 28% increase. This growth may indicate the bank's proactive approach in extending credit facilities to businesses and individuals. Similarly, CRDB Bank exhibited a robust performance in this area with a loan and advances portfolio of 8.5 trillion Tanzania Shillings, reflecting a commendable 23% growth.

Moving on to profitability, NMB Bank demonstrated strong financial results. The bank reported a profit before tax of 775 billion Tanzania Shillings, indicating a notable 26% increase. Additionally, the profit after tax for NMB Bank amounted to 542 billion Tanzania Shillings, reflecting a similar 26% growth. These figures underscore the bank's ability to generate profits efficiently, possibly through effective cost management and revenue generation strategies.

CRDB Bank, while also delivering positive financial results, exhibited a profit before tax of 599 billion Tanzania Shillings, showing a 20% increase. The profit after tax for CRDB Bank stood at 424 billion Tanzania Shillings, reflecting a 21% growth. These figures indicate the bank's capacity to maintain solid profitability, although at a slightly lower growth rate compared to NMB Bank.

Hence, both NMB Bank and CRDB Bank demonstrated commendable financial performance for the period ended December 31, 2023, with NMB Bank showcasing higher growth rates in key areas such as total assets, total deposits, loan and advances, as well as profitability. These financial indicators provide valuable insights into the operational efficiency and market competitiveness of the two banks during the specified period.

The health and competitiveness of these banks in the Tanzania financial sector:

The financial data reveals that both NMB Bank and CRDB Bank are robust financial institutions, with NMB Bank showcasing higher growth rates in key areas. Investors, regulators, and other stakeholders may use this information to assess the banks' financial health, operational strategies, and overall market competitiveness.

Asset Growth and Stability:

NMB Bank has shown a higher growth rate in total assets (19%) compared to CRDB Bank (14%). This suggests that NMB Bank has been successful in expanding its asset base, possibly through strategic investments or acquisitions, making it a key player in the market.

Deposit Mobilization:

Both banks experienced growth in total deposits, indicating the ability to attract and retain customer funds. NMB Bank's 11% growth in deposits may suggest effective deposit mobilization efforts, while CRDB Bank, with an 8% growth, also demonstrated strength in this area but at a slightly lower rate.

Lending Activities:

Both banks exhibited substantial growth in loan and advances portfolios, suggesting active participation in lending to businesses and individuals. NMB Bank's 28% growth and CRDB Bank's 23% growth in this category indicate a willingness to extend credit and support economic activities.

Profitability:

NMB Bank reported higher growth rates in both profit before tax (26%) and profit after tax (26%) compared to CRDB Bank, which reported a 20% growth in profit before tax and a 21% growth in profit after tax. This signifies that NMB Bank was more efficient in managing costs or generating revenues during the specified period.

Overall Competitiveness:

The data suggests that NMB Bank had a relatively stronger financial performance during this period, with higher growth rates in key metrics. However, CRDB Bank also demonstrated positive growth across various parameters, indicating its stability and competitiveness in the market.

Market Positioning:

NMB Bank's higher growth rates across multiple financial indicators might position it as a more dynamic and rapidly growing institution. CRDB Bank, while still showing positive growth, might be perceived as slightly more conservative or stable in its approach.

The forecasting performance in the coming year (2024) requires consideration of various factors, including economic conditions, regulatory changes, and the banks' strategic initiatives.

Growth Trajectory:

nmb-q4-2023Download
crdb-q4-2023Download
crossmenu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram